“The singers wanted to overshout each other, they were frequently out of tune, the sound uneven, the conducting without any artistic power, the organ and organ playing like in a second-rank country parish church.” So says, The International Church Music Review about the Sistine Chapel Choir. And that choir is about a thousand times better than most parish choirs, far removed from the watchful eye of the pope. Pope Benedict has said no more! And, this blogger hopes the new direction at the Vatican spreads to parishes across the world (or at least in Central Indiana).
The liberalizing influences of the implementation of the Second Vatican Council have destroyed the sacred nature of worship spaces in the Catholic Church. Speaking of my own experience within my own parish, we have imported guitars, bongos, tambourines and drum sets. One night a month we have a veritable lounge act where the singer sings, at times, heretical songs at the tops of his lungs.
A couple of weeks ago, we had an excellent homily that talked about the Catholic Church’s teaching on the body, the true humanity of Jesus, and the resurrection of our bodies. The recessional song? We were treated to a borderline Docetist hymn which directly contradicted the homily! It was unbelievable! (I wish I could remember exactly which song it was and recite some of the lyrics – it was probably some Marty Haugen song out of the insipid GIA Publication hymnals that are in use in virtually every parish in America). I remember looking in alarm at my wife and noting that she’d detected the same heresy right on the heels of a homily dealing with the subject. I was stunned and was more than a little angry. I’m not alone.
It is good to see Pope Benedict (or as we call him around the house, Pope Benny the Awesome) taking the issue of liturgical music seriously. Let him who has ears to listen be spared listening to insipid, heretic Gnostic Bravo Sierra! Amen.
Update: Compare for yourself.
Continue Reading »