Thanks for stopping in. Without having read Gonzalez, I can only agree that the film could have (but didn’t) explore the question of whether ID makes a compelling argument.

Surely, Stein had his reasons for including the Nazi side trip in his movie. I simply found it to be a digression from his main point. However, I suppose when I make my movie, I can do it however I like. Stein is entitled to the same.

And, if I’m lucky, Stein will take me to task over some of my decisions.

I’m not sure that Stein made the film based on pragmatism, he seems to be seeking the truth and it’s true that Darwinism is linked to Nazism.

I agree with you though. Personally I would have enjoyed more on ID type reasoning or interesting bits of knowledge which cause censorship. In the case of Gonzalez they could have illustrated at least a little of the evidence of a correlation between habitability and discoverability. And so on…

I have often wondered why “The Academy” treats ID researchers like Holocaust Deniers.